Recruiter Vs Talent Advisor: Which Role Does Your Business Need?

What is even more interesting is the fact that in this rapid world of talent acquisition, a company has a serious dilemma as to whether they should employ a recruiter or a talent advisor. This is because even though both involve sourcing and attracting talent, there are different values and ways in which they go about doing this.

The Recruiter Trap:

Recruiters are often viewed as the sequence or order acceptors and this may include the love to get it done even if in the wrong way within the Alliance. To begin with, they may fixate on the process of placing people into clear existent jobs as fast as they can, even disregarding the consequences of poor quality leads or worse, productivity dips.

‍

The Talent Advisor Advantage:

Talent advisors take an approach that is called strategic. They engage in more than simply filling job orders – they seek to understand the organization and its culture. Instead, they spend time courting candidates for a better match of the company and the individual.

‍

Key Differences:

Focus: Recruiters are in the business of filling roles while talent advisors are interested in getting the best person for your organization.

Approach: Many times, recruiters have a short-term view but there are those talent advisors who have a long-term view.

Value Proposition: Recruiters are more inclined to use a service-oriented approach while talent advisors are more inclined to give advice and assistance.

‍

Understanding the Roles

What is a Recruiter?

Consider the recruiter a pro archer, searching for a candidate worthy of attention. In other words, the recruiter has to get the particular vacancy filled at the earliest possible without much concern about the fit in the long term.

What is a Talent Advisor?

Think of a talent advisor as a brilliant tactician looking down on the warring parties from the trees. Such an advisor does not seek only the filling of the vacancy but also the person who will best fit the role in terms of a specific mission of the company. They value less the time within which the task is completed and more how effective the work is going to be in the future.

Therefore, in this case, a recruiter takes on the role of a frontiersman, and the talent advisor takes on the role of a strategist. These are two equally relevant functions within the matter of recruitment, however, their methods and aims vary quite a lot, in the latter half of this statement.

Key Differences Between Recruiters and Talent Advisors

Although there is a great deal of overlap between the two roles of recruiter and talent advisor, there is a great deal of difference in their approach, responsibilities, and value proposition. This is a summary of the main differences:

‍

Hiring Demands and Expectations

Recruiters: Tend to pay a lot of attention to crowding and solving the existing gaps and problems of the solicitations in a given point of time.

Talent Advisors: On the other hand, expand the area inwards as outward thinking including the time value of treasuring assets for the strategic growth of the business which the employee will aide sustain.

‍

Affairs of the Organization

Recruiters: Mostly tend to rigidly abide by the recruitment model and system and most, if not all, use the applicant tracking systems (ATS) to supervise candidates.

Talent Advisors: Some may use all the applicable and merits within the turn key solution offering, hence this is more suited to addressing the recruitment backbone aspect of the particular organizational culture.

‍

Monetary considerations

Recruiters: More often than not, work towards a specific budget and are likely to be more economical due to financial considerations.

Talent Advisors: Might have a less rigid financial policy and as such are able to pump more resources including employers’ branding and reputation management to lure potential employees.

‍

Value Proposition

Recruiters: Tend to concentrate on recruiting as most of their activities focus on ‘filling the gap’ rather than employment strategies.

Talent Advisors: That is a more defensive position, so they explain how to Staff, Brand, and Plan for the future of the organization.

‍

In the simplest terms, recruiters are the doers and talent advisors are the thinkers. These two roles are both critical, however their workings give way to a more sensible approach to agitating any organization’s employment needs.

‍

How to Decide Which Role Your Business Needs

So, which one of these positions makes more sense for your business? Your particular requirements, ambitions, and resources will dictate the answer.

If you are a small company with restricted resources and want to fill turnaround vacancies, then a recruiter will be enough. However, in the case of larger corporations where there is a long-term strategy to be followed as retention and acquisition of highly skilled employees a talent advisor comes in handy. When making a decision, consider the next aspects:

• The size and the resources of the firm.
• Your vision of the future in relation to the business.
• The complexity of hiring needs.
• Investing in hiring and recruiting budgets.

‍

Evaluating these factors will assist you in making a prudent choice that will benefit your organization in meeting its recruiting goals.

‍

Key Questions to Ask Before Choosing

Before arriving at any decisions, think hard about the below issues:

1. Long-Term Hiring Goals:  

• What is your long-run strategy for recruitment? Is it to satisfy an existing need or is it to build an organization with talent bases found elsewhere?  
• How do you reconcile the factors of recruiting and your business strategy?  

2. Current State of Talent Acquisition:    

• Do you have a problem attracting, holding and developing the best people?  
• What particular part of your recruitment process needs an overhaul?  

3. Employer Branding;    

• How does your company view employer branding? Do you want to become known as the employer of choice?  
• How have you gone about creating an employer brand?  

4. Budget and Investment:  

• What’s your spend on talent acquisition? How much are your costs for hiring services?  
• Do you have a minimum cost optimum or a return expectation or both?  

5. Industry Expertise and Niche Requirements:  

• Are there any occupations or niches, which you must include, that are technology specific?  
• Do you have a need to a recruiter or a talent advisor in your area of expertise?  

6. Data-Driven Decision Making:  

• How much emphasis does your organization place on data-driven decision-making?  
• Is it necessary for you to work with someone who can provide statistics or analytics for your recruitment techniques?  

7. Communication Style and Involvement:

• What is your communication style and preferred level of involvement? Do you prefer to have little involvement or maintain a ‘working together level’?  
• How significant is the element of availability and updates from a recruiter or a talent advisor in your working relations?  

By asking yourself these questions, you will understand the factors necessary for making the decision and pick an appropriate associate for the fulfillment of your organization’s talent acquisition.

‍

Conclusion

Whether to hire a recruiter or a talent advisor is similar to using the right-tool-for-the-right-application principle. Both of them can be useful when looking for top talent, but the differences in their methods and expertise are substantial.

‍

Now, here is a summary of the essential distinctions: 

Focus: While recruiters seek to fill vacancies, talent advisors’s goal is to identify individuals who will be an asset to the organization.

Approach: Recruiters are often transactional in nature while talent advisors strategize for a long-term working relationship.

Proposition of value - Recruiters provide a service that is transactional, but talent advisors support the strategy. 

‍

Last but not least, kindly give consideration to the following when making any purchase or hiring decision:

• The scope of your company and the available resources
• The long-term aspirations you have in mind
• The degree of your recruitment needs
• The financial provisions you have for seeking and acquiring qualified candidates

‍

Always remember that no response is assured. The most suitable and appropriate choice for your company will rest on the particular needs and priorities of the organization in question. Be inquisitive and look for alternative possibilities. A recruiter or talent advisor is potentially beneficial to your team but only as much as the goals and values match within the two. In the end, it is your call. Do a self-assessment and identification of the best partner that will assist you in achieving your hiring goals.

‍

If you’re a recruiter or a talent advisor, you can benefit from Nurturebox in the following ways:

Improve productivity: Minimise the dealing of manual tasks and enhance the hiring process.

Candidate experience: Give candidates a good enjoyable experience.

Cost saving: Automate processes and ease the workflows thereby saving time and money.

Go beyond intuition and guesswork: Harness the power of analytics to refine your hiring strategies.